Trädgård & frost

How much does horticultural fleece help against frost?

Tre frostskyddshuvar av fiberduk över krukväxter på en balkong

Horticultural fleece is a thin, airy fabric that you lay loosely over plants. It works like a light blanket. At night it holds on to some of the heat from the ground, and it softens the wind. That is often enough on a clear autumn night or a late frost in May. Against severe cold, and against spring sun on evergreens, it is the wrong tool.

How much does horticultural fleece protect against frost?

There is no Swedish measurement of how many degrees horticultural fleece gives. We haven't found any Swedish authority or research source that states a figure. The Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) says that thicker fleece gives roughly 2 degrees of frost protection. Treat it as a rough guide, not a guarantee. The protection depends on how cold the night gets, whether it is windy, how much heat the ground has stored and how thick the fleece is.

The closest thing to a Swedish measurement is a student thesis from SLU Alnarp, the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (Ljungberg and Svensson, 2014). They measured the temperature under different fleeces on two farms in Skåne, in southern Sweden, in April and May. On the coldest night the sensor without fleece showed −1.1 °C on one of the farms. The 30 g fleece and a double layer of 17 g fleece kept the warmth best then. The thinner fleeces let it escape faster.

The thesis's literature review says that fleece does not give full protection once it gets colder than roughly −4 °C, but that it can reduce the damage. So fleece is enough for light frost.

Can it get too warm under horticultural fleece?

Yes. The same thesis also measured sunny days. In late April it reached just over 48 °C under a 22 g fleece, against 36–40 °C without. The difference was 9 °C on one farm and 12.4 °C on the other. The trial was done on farmland, not on potted plants, but fleece traps the sun's heat in the same way over a pot.

The heat can help new sowings in spring but harms plants that should rest over winter.

Can you use horticultural fleece in winter?

Not on evergreens, meaning plants that keep their leaves or needles over winter, such as rhododendron, box and yew. The advisers at the Swedish gardening association Riksförbundet Svensk Trädgård (Svensk Trädgård for short) advise against fleece as winter protection for tender evergreens. The fleece traps the sun's heat and warms the plant up. Water in the tissue can then freeze on a cold night and burst the cell walls. The sun also makes the leaves lose water, and when the ground is frozen the roots can't take up any more. The plant dries out, which is known as winter desiccation. Brown leaves or needles between April and June are a sign of it.

The advisers recommend hessian or green shade netting instead. Cover mainly the side that gets sun. The hessian also softens the wind. The protection can stay on from just after New Year until around mid-April.

Deciduous shrubs have no leaves to dry out, but they too can wake too early in the warmth under the fleece and then be damaged when the frost returns.

Which horticultural fleece should you choose?

Svensk Trädgård asked amateur growers about their fleeces in its Trädgårdsspanarna ("garden spotters") project. The advice was to avoid the thinnest fleeces at 17 g/m² and to choose 22 g/m² or heavier. Thicker fleece lasts longer and insulates better against the cold. Cheap, thin fleeces got the most criticism, and some fell apart within four to eight weeks.

Fleece Light let through (manufacturer's figure) Coldest night in Alnarp Svensk Trädgård's advice
17 g/m² 85% Let the warmth escape faster Avoid, tears easily
22 g/m² 79% Let the warmth escape faster Lowest recommended weight
30 g/m² 75% Kept the warmth best Lasts longer, insulates better
2 layers of 17 g/m² Not stated Kept the warmth best No information

The light figures apply to the fleeces in the Alnarp trial. Other brands may differ.

Does horticultural fleece let water through?

Yes, fleece isn't waterproof. Rain and a watering can both get through, and when growing strawberries people often water straight through the fabric. It also lets air and most of the light through, so it can stay over plants for several weeks in spring. Plastic doesn't breathe. Under a plastic bag the moisture stays in, and in sun it quickly gets hot.

When should the fleece go on and come off?

On: According to SMHI, the Swedish meteorological institute, frost most often forms when the sky is clear and the wind is light. Put the fleece on in the afternoon on days when the forecast shows a clear, cold night, while the ground still holds the day's warmth. Weather stations measure two metres above the ground, and at ground level it can be considerably colder. Low plants can therefore freeze even though the forecast shows temperatures above zero.

Off: Fold the fleece back when the sun comes out and temperatures rise above freezing. Over strawberries it should come off when they flower, otherwise bees and other insects can't reach the flowers.

In spring: Take the fleece off completely once the frosty nights are over. SMHI points out that the odd frosty night can come right into early summer and that the old farmers' calendar dates have no support in the statistics. Follow the forecast, not the almanac.

In autumn: The first frosty night arrives at different times in different parts of the country. According to a map from Swedish Television (SVT), based on SMHI data, it normally comes in early August in parts of Jämtland and Härjedalen in northern Sweden but not until late November along the Götaland coast in the south. With fleece over them, dahlias and late vegetables cope with the first light frosty nights.

Step-by-step instructions follow further down.

What is the best way to protect plants from frost?

It depends on the plant and the time of year.

Protection Best for Keep in mind
Horticultural fleece on a roll Beds, strawberries, new sowings and low plants in spring and autumn Secure the edges and fold back in sun
Sewn fleece cover Individual potted plants and shrubs during frosty nights and wind Same material as the fleece, so open it up in sun
Hessian or green shade netting Evergreens from New Year to April, and windy spots Gives shade and wind protection, not warmth
Plastic bag Emergency fix for a single night Doesn't breathe, take it off in the morning

For individual pots there are ready-made covers. Our Vinterhuv is a fleece cover with a zip and drawstring, which stays put in wind without clothes pegs. It follows the same rules as all fleece: open the zip or take it off on sunny days, and choose hessian for evergreens in spring sun.

You'll find more ways to protect pots in our guide Overwintering potted plants outdoors. Roses have their own tricks, such as earthing up and spruce branches, and we go through them in Winter protection for roses. You'll find more for the garden under Outdoor & Garden.

Common mistakes

  • The fleece goes on only when it's already freezing. Put it on in the afternoon, while the ground is warm.
  • The fleece is left on in blazing sun. In the Alnarp trial it reached over 48 °C under the fleece.
  • Fleece on evergreens in February and March. Use hessian or green shade netting.
  • The thinnest fleece, because it's the cheapest. 17 g/m² insulates worst and tears most easily.
  • The fleece is pulled tight. Lay it loosely. A fleece pressing against the plants can damage them.
  • The edges aren't secured. Then the fleece blows off or lets in cold air from underneath.
  • The fleece is left to cope with severe cold alone. When the cold sets in, frost-tender potted plants need to come into a cool, frost-free room.

Sources

Step by step

1

Kolla prognosen

Frostrisken är störst en klar och vindstilla natt. Låga plantor kan frysa även när prognosen visar några plusgrader, eftersom det blir kallare vid markytan än två meter upp där temperaturen mäts.

2

Välj tjocklek

Ta minst 22 g/m². Inför kallare nätter ger 30 g/m² eller två lager tunn duk mer skydd.

3

Lägg på duken på eftermiddagen

Lägg duken löst över plantorna eller över bågar, ända ner till marken. Den får ligga direkt på bladen men ska inte spännas.

4

Fäst kanterna

Tyng ner kanterna med stenar, plankor, jord eller fiberdukshållare, så att vinden inte lyfter duken.

5

Vik undan i sol

När solen kommer fram och det blir plusgrader viker du undan duken eller öppnar huven. Lägg tillbaka den inför nästa kalla natt.

6

Ta bort när frostrisken är över

Ta bort duken när prognosen inte längre visar frost. Över jordgubbar ska den av när de blommar. På vintergröna växter byter du till juteväv eller grön skuggväv efter nyår.

Products in the guide

Vinterhuv frostskyddshuv över en kruka – 30 dagars pengarna tillbakaVinterhuv sänks över en buske och slätas till runt krukan

FAQ

How long does horticultural fleece last?

It depends mostly on the thickness. In a Svensk Trädgård survey, some thin fleeces fell apart within four to eight weeks, while one grower had used the same 30 gsm fleece for six seasons. Sunlight (UV), wind and animals all wear the fleece down. A fleece should last at least one season to be worth the money.

Does double-layer fleece help against frost?

Yes. In a student thesis from SLU Alnarp (the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences), two layers of 17 gsm fleece kept the warmth in about as well as a 30 gsm fleece on the coldest night, and better than a single layer. On sunny days it didn't get as warm under the thicker options as under the 22 gsm fleece, but it still reached around 37 °C. Fold the fleece back when the sun is strong.

Is fleece or plastic better against frost?

Fleece, in most cases. It lets air, light and water through, so it can stay in place for several days. Plastic doesn't breathe, so moisture stays trapped underneath and in the sun it quickly gets hot. A plastic bag will do as an emergency fix for a single night, but take it off in the morning.

Can you put fleece over strawberries?

Yes. Fleece is common in strawberry growing and can be laid straight onto the plants. It protects against late spring frost and can give an earlier harvest. Take the fleece off when the strawberries flower, otherwise bees and other insects can't reach the flowers and pollination suffers.

Are fleece and weed membrane the same thing?

No. Two quite different products get called fleece. Growing fleece of about 17–30 g/m² is the thin white sheet you lay over plants against frost. Building fleece (geotextile) is a heavy-duty fabric laid under gravel and paving slabs. Weed membrane is laid on the ground to stop weeds. Only the thin growing fleece works as frost protection.